Benefts in behaviourally disturbed patients
Previous research indicates that AD patients with agitation/aggression and psychotic features deteriorate more rapidly.47-50 However, there are concerns over the safe use of atypical antipsychotic agents in patients with dementia.51-53
A pooled analysis was performed on memantine studies in moderate to severe AD (MRZ-9605, MD-01, MD-02) to assess the specifc effects of memantine in behaviourally disturbed patients ¨C that is, in patients with ¡®agitation/aggression¡¯ and ¡®psychosis¡¯ at baseline.54 The Behaviourally Disturbed Population (BDP), comprised patients scoring >0 on any of three NPI items ¨C ¡®delusions¡¯, ¡®hallucinations¡¯, and/or ¡®agitation/aggression¡¯ ¨C at baseline.
Cluster of behavioural items
Memantine signifcantly improved the NPI sub-item cluster of ¡®agitation and psychosis¡¯ (combined score of the ¡®delusions¡¯, ¡®hallucinations¡¯, and ¡®agitation/aggression¡¯ items) versus placebo deterioration at both Week 12 (-0.8 points vs 0.5 points; p<0.01) and Week 24/28 (-0.7 points vs 0.7 points; p<0.001).54
There were signifcantly more responders (improvement in NPI cluster score from baseline) in the memantine group than in the placebo group at Week 12 (55% vs 43%; p<0.05), and Week 24/28 (61% vs 45%; p<0.01) (Figure 6.15).54
In the subgroup of patients without the NPI sub-item cluster of ¡®agitation and psychosis¡¯ at baseline (i.e., non-BDP, asymptomatic), memantine prevented the emergence of these symptoms, with signifcantly fewer patients developing the symptoms at Week 12 (20% vs 32%; p=0.01) and at Week 24/28 (24% vs 37%; p<0.01), as compared with placebo.54
Global, cognitive, functional and behavioural domains
Memantine produced a signifcant beneft over placebo for all four main outcome measures: total scores for SIB, CIBIC-Plus, ADCS-ADLsev (Figure 6.16), OC and LOCF analyses.54
The treatment effects were larger in the BDP patients, compared with the total population, mostly due to a larger decline in the BDP placebo group (Figure 6.16).31
At study endpoint (Week 24/28, LOCF), approximately half of the memantine-treated BDP patients were either stabilised or improved relative to baseline across these three measures.54
Effect of memantine discontinuation on psychotropic drug use and body weight (Fillit et al, 2008)55
This study set out to assess the association between memantine discontinuation and changes in psychotropic drug utilisation, and body weight, in nursing home residents with AD.
Data from medical charts of subjects aged ¡Ý50 years, and living in nursing homes for ¡Ý90 days were collected from nursing homes in the US. Comparisons were made between two groups (n=521):
residents who took memantine continuously for ¡Ý90 days (n=273)
residents who took memantine for ¡Ý30 days and then discontinued for ¡Ý60 days (n=248).
Results
As shown in Figure 6.17, compared with nursing home residents who were continuously maintained on memantine, discontinuation of memantine for ¡Ý60 days was associated with signifcantly higher odds of increased use of:
psychotropic drugs (32.3% vs 16.5%; OR=2.29; p<0.001)
anticonvulsants (OR=5.95; p=0.005)
antidepressants (OR=3.21; p<0.001)
antipsychotics (OR=2.27; p=0.012)
anxiolytics (OR=2.53; p=0.01).
The effect was not signifcant for sedatives/hypnotics (OR=1.45; p=0.60).
Residents who discontinued memantine experienced adjusted mean (¡À SEM) weight loss of 1.20 ¡À 0.32 kg (p<0.001) compared to a weight gain of 0.34 ¡À 0.29 kg in those who took memantine continuously.
The study concluded that in comparing continuous administration and discontinuation of memantine in nursing home residents with AD, discontinuation of memantine therapy was associated with higher odds of increased psychotropic drug use (including anticonvulsants, antidepressants, antipsychotics, and anxiolytics) and with signifcant weight loss.
ÐÐΪÕÏ°»¼ÕßµÄÊÜÒæ
Ç°ÃæµÄÑо¿±íÃ÷£º¾ßÓн¹ÂÇ/¹¥»÷¼°¾«ÉñÖ¢×´ÌØÕ÷µÄAD»¼Õß²¡Çé¶ñ»¯¸ü¼Ó¿ìËÙ47-50¡£È»¶ø£¬¶Ô³Õ´ô»¼ÕßʹÓ÷ǵäÐÍ¿¹¾«Éñ²¡Ò©Îï¾ßÓа²È«ÐÔ·½ÃæµÄµ£ÐÄ51-53¡£
»ã×ÜÈýÏMRZ-9605¡¢ MD-01¡¢ MD-02£©¹ØÓÚÃÀ½ð¸ÕÖÎÁÆÖС¢ÖضÈAD»¼ÕßÑо¿µÄÊý¾Ý£¬ÆÀ¼ÛÃÀ½ð¸ÕÖÎÁÆÐÐΪÕÏ°»¼Õߣ¨¼´ÔÚ»ùÏß¾ßÓС°½¹ÂÇ/¹¥»÷¡±¼°¡°¾«Éñ²¡Ö¢×´¡±µÄ»¼Õߣ©µÄÌØÒìÐÔЧӦ54¡£ÐÐΪÕÏ°ÈËȺ°üÀ¨ÔÚÔÚ»ùÏßÈýÏîNPIϸÏ¡°ÍýÏ롱¡¢¡°»Ã¾õ¡±ºÍ/»ò¡°½¹ÂÇ/¹¥»÷¡±£©ÖÐÈÎÒ»Ò»ÏîÆÀ·Ö´óÓÚ¡°0¡±µÄ»¼Õß¡£
ÐÐΪÏî×éºÏ
Ó밲ο¼Á×éÏà±È£¬ÔÚµÚ12Öܼ°µÚ24/28ÖÜʱ£¬ÃÀ½ð¸Õ¼«´óµØ¸ÄÉÆNPIϸÏî¡°½¹ÂǼ°¾«ÉñÖ¢×´¡±£¨¼´¡°ÍýÏ롱¡¢¡°»Ã¾õ¡±¼°¡°½¹ÂÇ/¹¥»÷¡±ÏîµÄÁªºÏÆÀ·Ö£©×éºÏÆÀ·Ö£¬µÚ12ÖÜʱ£¨ÃÀ½ð¸Õ×飺-0.8·Ö£¬°²Î¿¼Á×飺0.5·Ö£»p<0.01£©£¬µÚ24/28ÖÜʱ£¨ÃÀ½ð¸Õ×飺-0.7·Ö£¬°²Î¿¼Á×飺0.7·Ö£»p<0.001£©54¡£
ÔÚµÚ12Öܼ°µÚ24/28ÖÜʱ£¬ÃÀ½ð¸Õ×éÓÐЧӦ´ðµÄ»¼Õß±ÈÀý£¨¸ÄÉÆNPI×éºÏÆÀ·Ö£©Ã÷ÏÔ¸ßÓÚ°²Î¿¼Á×飬µÚ12ÖÜʱ£¨ÃÀ½ð¸Õ×é×飺55%£¬°²Î¿¼Á£º43%£»p<0.05£©£¬µÚ24/28ÖÜʱ£¨ÃÀ½ð¸Õ×飺61%£¬°²Î¿¼Á£º45%£»p<0.01£©£¨Í¼6.15£©54¡£
ÔÚ»ùÏßÎÞNPI´Î¼¶Á¿±í×éºÏ¡°½¹ÂǼ°¾«ÉñÖ¢×´¡±µÄ»¼ÕßÑÇ×飨Ҳ¾ÍÊÇ˵·ÇÐÐΪÕÏ°»¼Õߣ¬ÎÞÖ¢×´£©£¬ÃÀ½ð¸Õ¿ÉÒÔ·ÀÖ¹ÕâЩ֢״µÄ³öÏÖ£¬ÔÚµÚ12ÖÜ¡¢24/28ÖÜ£¬ÃÀ½ð¸Õ×é³öÏÖÕâЩ֢״µÄ»¼ÕßÃ÷ÏÔµÍÓÚÓ밲ο¼Á×飬µÚ12ÖÜ£¨ÃÀ½ð¸Õ×飺20%£¬°²Î¿¼Á×飺32%£»p=0.01£©£¬µÚ24/28ÖÜ£¨ÃÀ½ð¸Õ×飺24%£¬°²Î¿¼Á×飺37%£»p<0.01£©54¡£
ÕûÌå×´¿ö¡¢ÈÏÖªÄÜÁ¦¡¢¹¦Äܼ°ÐÐΪÓò
Ó밲ο¼Á×éÏà±È£¬ÃÀ½ð¸ÕÄܸø»¼ÕßÔÚËĸöÖ÷Òª½á¹ûÆÀ¼Û·½Ãæ´øÀ´Ã÷ÏÔÊÜÒ棺SIB×Ü·Ö¡¢CIBIC-Plus¡¢ADCS-ADLsev£¨Í¼6.16£©£¬OC·ÖÎö¼°LOCF·ÖÎö54¡£
Óë×Ü»¼ÕßÈËȺÏà±È£¬BDP»¼ÕßµÄÖÎÁÆЧÓøü´ó£¬Ö÷ÒªÊÇÒòΪÔÚBDP°²Î¿¼Á×黼ÕߵIJ¡Çé¶ñ»¯¸ü¼ÓѸËÙ£¨Í¼6.16£©¡£31
ÔÚÑо¿Öյ㣨24//28ÖÜ£¬LOCF£©£¬´óÔ¼Ò»°ëµÄÃÀ½ð¸ÕÖÎÁƵÄBDP»¼ÕßÔÚÕâÈýÏîÆÀ¼ÛÖ¸±ê·½Ã没ÇéÎȶ¨£¬»òÕ߽ϻùÏß³öÏÖ¸ÄÉÆ¡£54
ÖжÏÃÀ½ð¸ÕÖÎÁƶԾ«ÉñÒ©ÎïʹÓü°ÌåÖصÄÓ°Ï죨Fillit µÈ£¬ 2008£©55
¸ÃÑо¿ÆÀ¼Û»¤ÀíÔºµÄAD»¼ÕßÖжÏÃÀ½ð¸ÕÖÎÁÆÓëʹÓÿ¹¾«Éñ²¡Ò©Îï¼°ÌåÖظıäÖ®¼äµÄ¹Øϵ¡£
´ÓÃÀ¹ú»¤ÀíÔºµÄ²¡ÀúÖÐÊÕ¼¯Êý¾ÝµÄÊÜÊÔÕßÄêÁä¡Ý50Ë꣬ÔÚ»¤ÀíÔºµÄÉú»îʱ¼ä¡Ý90Ìì¡£¶ÔÒÔÏÂÁ½¸ö×éÖ®¼äµÄ»¼Õß½øÐбȽϣ¨n=521£©£º
Á¬Ðø·þÓÃÃÀ½ð¸Õ¡Ý90ÌìµÄ»¼Õߣ¨n=273£©
Á¬Ðø·þÓÃÃÀ½ð¸Õ¡Ý30Ìì¡¢²¢ÇÒÖжϷþÓÃÃÀ½ð¸Õ¡Ý60ÌìµÄ»¼Õߣ¨n=248£©
½á¹û
Èç6.17Ëùʾ£¬ÔÚ»¤ÀíÔºÁ¬Ðø·þÓÃÃÀ½ð¸ÕµÄ»¼ÕßÓëÖжÏÃÀ½ð¸ÕÖÎÁÆ¡Ý60ÌìµÄ»¼Õß½øÐбȽϷ¢ÏÖ£¬ÖжÏÃÀ½ð¸ÕÖÎÁƵĻ¼Õß×éʹÓÃÒÔÏÂÒ©ÎïµÄ±ÈÀý¸ü¸ß£º
¾«ÉñÖÎÁÆÒ©ÎÖжÏÃÀ½ð¸ÕÖÎÁÆ×飺32.3%£¬Á¬Ðø·þÓÃÃÀ½ð¸Õ×é16.5%£»OR£¨±ÈÖµ±È£©=2.29£»p<0.001£©
¿¹¾ªØÊÒ©£¨OR£¨±ÈÖµ±È£©=5.95£»p=0.005£©
¿¹ÒÖÓôÒ©£¨OR£¨±ÈÖµ±È£©=3.21£»p<0.001£©
¿¹¾«Éñ²¡Ò©£¨OR£¨±ÈÖµ±È£©=2.27£» p=0.012£©
¿¹½¹ÂǼÁ£¨OR£¨±ÈÖµ±È£©=2.53£» p=0.01£©
ʹÓÃÕò¾²¼Á/°²ÃßÒ©µÄЧÓò»Ã÷ÏÔ£¨OR£¨±ÈÖµ±È£©=1.45£»p=0.60£©¡£
ÖжÏÃÀ½ð¸ÕÖÎÁƵĻ¼ÕßУÕýƽ¾ù£¨¡ÀSEM£©ÌåÖؼõÇá1.20 ¡À 0.32 kg£¬¶øÁ¬Ðø·þÓÃÃÀ½ð¸ÕµÄ»¼Õßƽ¾ùÌåÖØÔö¼Ó0.34 ¡À 0.29 kg£¨p<0.001£©¡£
¸ÃÑо¿µÃ³ö½áÂÛ:¶Ô»¤ÀíÔºÁ¬Ðø·þÓÃÃÀ½ð¸ÕµÄAD»¼ÕßÓëÖжÏÃÀ½ð¸ÕÖÎÁƵÄAD»¼Õß½øÐбȽϷ¢ÏÖ£¬ÖжÏÃÀ½ð¸ÕÖÎÁƵ¼Ö»¼Õß·þÓþ«ÉñÖÎÁÆÒ©Î°üÀ¨¿¹¾ªØÊÒ©¡¢¿¹ÒÖÓôÒ©¡¢¿¹¾«Éñ²¡Ò©¼°¿¹½¹ÂÇÒ©£©µÄ±ÈÀýÔö¼Ó£¬²¢ÇÒµ¼ÖÂÃ÷ÏÔµÄÌåÖؼõÇá¡£
Ô¼þÏÂÔØ£º
|